The Howard Roarke of Economics

Flattr this!

By David Law­son
‘“Men have been taught that it is virtue to agree with oth­ers. But the cre­ator is the man who dis­agrees. Men have been taught that it is virtue to swim with the cur­rent. But the cre­ator is the man who goes against the cur­rent. Men have been taught that it is virtue to stand togeth­er. But the cre­ator stands alone.”’[1]

For those who are unfa­mil­iar with this quote, it is tak­en from The Foun­tain­head, by Ayn Rand, and I rec­om­mend it as a high­ly amus­ing fic­tion­al read. I do find it rather iron­ic that this quote is eas­i­ly applic­a­ble to Pro­fes­sor Steve Keen’s con­struc­tive­ly cre­ative approach to eco­nom­ic the­o­ry. Sad­ly, neo­clas­si­cal eco­nom­ics— today’s con­ven­tion­al eco­nom­ic current–is the sec­ond han­der of this defunct “free mar­ket” eco­nom­ic pos­tu­late that Ayn Rand helped cul­ti­vate through her far right-wing phi­los­o­phy of Objec­tivism. If neo­clas­si­cal eco­nom­ics is a reli­gion, then Objec­tivism is more of a cult! Even more amus­ing than her fic­tion­al  nov­els them­selves, was that Ayn Rand refused to drink her own Kool-Aid when she used the very wel­fare sys­tem that she spent her life cam­paign­ing against.

How­ev­er, the igno­rance of her sec­ond hand fol­low­ers is more dis­turb­ing than amus­ing. Her so called mas­ter­piece Atlas Shugged has been called the sec­ond most influ­en­tial book to the bible in the Unit­ed States. Alan Greenspan, win­ner of the Dyna­mite Prize, acknowl­edged it, say­ing that “Atlas Shrugged is a cel­e­bra­tion of life and hap­pi­ness”. Oth­er sec­ond han­ders of Rand’s unsound phi­los­o­phy, Don­ald Luskin & Andrew Gre­ta, who wrote the book I am John Galt, claimed in it that “Mil­ton Fried­man… made eco­nom­ics into a sci­ence…”

Read­ers of this blog, and Steve’s Debunk­ing Eco­nom­ics, should be aware how absurd it is to char­ac­terise eco­nom­ics as a science—let alone the Neo­clas­si­cal vein that Fried­man pro­mot­ed with claims like:

The soci­eties that have achieved the most spec­tac­u­lar, broad-based eco­nom­ic progress in the short­est peri­od of time, are not the most tight­ly con­trolled, not nec­es­sar­i­ly the biggest in size or the wealth­i­est in nat­ur­al resources. No, what unites them all is their will­ing­ness to believe in the mag­ic of the mar­ket­place. [2]

Mag­ic? Friedman’s claims aren’t sci­en­tif­ic, they are a paean to an illu­sion! Mean­while, Mil­ton Fried­man, was Reagan’s eco­nom­ic advis­er and once described by Joan Robin­son as “… a man who would put a rab­bit into a hat, in full view in front of an audi­ence and expect applause as a magi­cian when he pulled it out short­ly after­wards”. Even his mag­ic was sec­ond hand.

Fried­man, who played a pri­ma­ry role in van­quish­ing mon­ey, banks and debt from eco­nom­ic the­o­ry, is also well known for his quote;

            … infla­tion is always and every­where a mon­e­tary phe­nom­e­non … [3]

How­ev­er, in the exces­sive­ly lever­aged and euphor­i­cal­ly pros­per­ous econ­o­my built on Friedman’s delu­sions, broad mon­ey expo­nen­tial­ly devi­ates from the mon­ey base, mak­ing moral haz­ard always and every­where an eco­nom­ic phe­nom­e­non!

Australian Money Supply

Source: [4]

As renowned Amer­i­can Physi­cist, Pro­fes­sor Albert Allen Bartlett once famous­ly said;

The great­est short­com­ing of the human race is our inabil­i­ty to under­stand the expo­nen­tial func­tion.’

How­ev­er, I do not believe this state­ment to be ful­ly cor­rect. I am sure that today’s bank­ing author­i­ties like Ben Bernanke and Glenn Stevens under­stand the expo­nen­tial func­tion quite well. What they ignore are its impli­ca­tions for their sec­ond hand Neo­clas­si­cal the­o­ries. Their Peter Keat­ing approach to solv­ing the Glob­al Finan­cial Cri­sis clear­ly lacks sus­tain­able cre­ativ­i­ty. Unfor­tu­nate­ly, the great­est short­com­ing of the human race is sim­ply human igno­rance, and Ayn Rand was tes­ta­ment to this fact.

Ref­er­ences:

[1] ‘The Foun­tain­head’, Ayn Rand, p. 713, Pen­guin Books, 2007, Eng­land.

[2] ‘The Counter-Rev­o­lu­tion in Mon­e­tary The­o­ry’ (Occa­sion­al Paper 33), Mil­ton Fried­man, p. 24, The Insti­tute of Eco­nom­ic Affairs: The Win­cott Foun­da­tion, 1970, Great Britain, Ton­bridge Print­ers Ltd.

[3] Ronald Rea­gan, for­mer Pres­i­dent of the Unit­ed States, in the film: Enron: The Smartest Guy In The Room by Alex Gib­ney (direc­tor), 2005.

[4] Based on Reserve Bank of Aus­tralia, ‘Sta­tis­tics, Finan­cial Aggre­gates, Mon­e­tary Aggre­gates – D3 [XLS]’ – elec­tron­ic deliv­ery. Release date: 30 April 2012. Avail­able at: <http://www.rba.gov.au/statistics/frequency/financial-aggregates.html>. Accessed 14 May 2012.

Bookmark the permalink.

About Steve Keen

I am Professor of Economics and Head of Economics, History and Politics at Kingston University London, and a long time critic of conventional economic thought. As well as attacking mainstream thought in Debunking Economics, I am also developing an alternative dynamic approach to economic modelling. The key issue I am tackling here is the prospect for a debt-deflation on the back of the enormous private debts accumulated globally, and our very low rate of inflation.